The Wounded Knee Massacre: The Forgotten History of the Native American Gun Confiscation

The Battle at Wounded Knee is a significant battle in American history, as it put an end to the Indian Wars and is marked as the last official defeat of the Native Americans. But what’s not taught in history lessons is that Wounded Knee was one of the first federally backed gun confiscations in the history of the United States, and it ended in the massacre of nearly 300 unarmed people.

During the late 19th century, American Indians were allowed to purchase and carry firearms, just as white men were. The colonial gun laws did not bar Native Americans from possessing firearms, yet that natural right was violated by government forces at Wounded Knee. And once the guns were confiscated, the battle ensued.

When we look at the issues surrounding gun confiscation, Wounded Knee gives us an example of the devastation that an unarmed people can experience at the hands of their own government. This battle serves as a reminder to fight against gun confiscation and the gun control legislation that can lead to it.

Leading Up to Wounded Knee

At the beginning of the 19th century, it’s estimated that 600,000 American Indians lived on the land that is now the United States. By the end of the century, the people diminished to less than 150,000.

Throughout the 1800s, these nomadic tribes were pushed from the open plains and forests into “Indian Territories,” places determined by the U.S. government. It started during the Creek Indian War (1813-1815), when American soldiers, led by Andrew Jackson, won nearly 20 million acres of land from the defeated Creek Indians.

Unlike George Washington, who believed in “civilizing” the Native Americans, Jackson favored an “Indian Removal,” and when president in 1830, he signed the Indian Removal Act, which was the first of many U.S. legislations that did not grant the Native Americans the same rights as colonial European-Americans. Davy Crockett was the only delegate from Tennessee to vote against the act.

The Plains Indians, who lived in the plains between the Mississippi River and the Rocky Mountains, weren’t as impacted by the U.S. government until later in the century, as U.S. expansion pushed into the “Wild West.” As people moved passed the Mississippi and into the Frontier, conflicts again arose between the Indians and Americans.

In an attempt at peace in 1851, the first Fort Laramie Treaty was signed, which granted the Plain Indians about 150 million acres of land for their own use as the Great Sioux Reservation. Then, 13 years later, the size was greatly reduced to about 60 million acres in the Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868, which recreated the Great Sioux Reservation boundaries and proclaimed all of South Dakota west of the Missouri river, including the Black Hills, solely for the Sioux Nation.

As part of the treaty, no unauthorized non-Indian was to come into the reservation and the Sioux were allowed to hunt in unceded Indian territory beyond the reservation that stretched into North Dakota, Montana, Wyoming, Nebraska, and Colorado. If any non-Indian wanted to settle on this unceded land, they could only do it with the permission of the Sioux.

That was until 1874, when gold was discovered in South Dakota’s Black Hills. The treaties that were signed between the Native Americans and the U.S. government were ignored as gold rushers invaded Indian Territory and issues arose, such as the Battle of the Little Bighorn.

As time went on, the American Indians continued to be pushed into smaller territories and their lives began to diminish. In 1889, the U.S. government issued the Dawes Act, which took the Black Hills from the Indians, broke up the Great Sioux Reservation into five separate reservations, and took nine million acres and opened it up for public purchase by non-Indians for homesteading and settlements.

The Native Americans were squeezed into these smaller territories and didn’t have enough game to support them. The bison that had been a staple to their way of life were gone. Their ancestral lands that sustained them were no longer theirs. The resistance was over. They were no longer free people, living amongst themselves, but “Redskins” confined by the “white man” in reservations they had been forced to, many against their will.

With all of the Sioux Nation inhabiting less than nine million acres, divided up throughout South Dakota, the Indians were encouraged by the U.S. government to develop small farms. But they were faced with poor, arid soil and a bad growing season, which led to a severely limited food supply in the year following the Dawes Act. A miscalculation in the census complicated matters even more when the population on the reservation was undercounted, leading to less supplies sent from the U.S. government.

The situation was beyond bleak and the Sioux people were starving. That winter, an influenza epidemic broke out and caused a disproportionate number of Sioux children to die. And then in the summer of 1890, a drought hit, destroying yet another season of crops and the people of Lakota Pine Ridge Indian Reservation were in dire condition.

The Ghost Dance

Perhaps it was these desolate circumstances that led to the spread of what is known as the Ghost Dance. Based on a vision experienced by a Sioux religious leader, the Ghost Dance was a spiritual ritual that was supposed to call the coming messiah, who would be an American Indian. This messiah would force the white man off of Indian lands, return the bison to the plains, and resurrect both their deceased and the life the Native Americans had once enjoyed.

Although this was not a war dance, it was feared by those who believed the Indians were savages. One such man was Daniel Royer, who arrived as the new agent on the Pine Ridge Reservation in October of 1890. He believed it to be a war dance and requested troops from President Benjamin Harrison on November 15th of that same year. His telegram read: “Indians are dancing in the snow and are wild and crazy. We need protection and we need it now.”

Harrison granted the request and part of the 7th Cavalry arrived on November 20th, with orders to arrest several Sioux leaders. Commander James Forsyth led the troops.

On December 15th, the 7th Cavalry attempted to arrest Sitting Bull, the Sioux chief who annihilated Commander George Custer in the Battle of the Little Bighorn (he also toured with Buffalo Bill’s Wild West Show and was a dear friend to Annie Oakley), because he didn’t attempt to stop the Ghost Dance amongst his people. During the incident, Sitting Bull was shot and killed.

The Lakota at Pine Ridge began to get nervous and the tribe’s leader, Big Foot, practiced the Ghost Dance and had caught the attention of the federal agents. After hearing of Sitting Bull’s death, he and his tribe fled to the Badlands.

They were pursued by the 7th Cavalry for five days. But Big Foot had come down with pneumonia and they were peacefully intercepted at Wounded Knee Creek on December 28th.

December 29, 1890: The Wounded Knee Massacre

The next morning, Col. Forsyth demanded that the tribe surrender their firearms. Rifles were being turned over without issue until some of the Sioux men started a Ghost Dance and began throwing dirt into the air, as was customary to the dance.

Tensions among the soldiers increased.

A few moments later, a Sioux man named Black Coyote refused to give up his rifle. It’s been reported that the Indian was deaf, had recently purchased the rifle, and was most likely unaware of why the soldier was demanding it. Regardless, the two began to skuffle and the gun discharged.

The 7th Cavalry, who was the reconstructed regiment of Custer, opened fire on the Lakota. Along with their own weapons, they used four Hotchkiss guns, a revolving barrel machine gun that could fire 68 rounds per minute, devastating the entire tribe, which had just peacefully handed over their weapons.

The Sioux men, women, and children scattered, and the Cavalry pursued them. Dead bodies were later found three miles from camp.

Once the firing ended, some two hours later, an estimated 300 Native Americans lay dead in the snow, at least half of them women and children. Those that didn’t die immediately froze to death during the oncoming blizzard.

Nearly a week later, on January 3, 1891, the Cavalry escorted a burial party to the banks of the Wounded Knee River and they buried 146 Lakota Indians in a single mass grave. Other bodies were found in the surrounding areas, and the estimated body count is between 250 and 300 Sioux.

The 7th Cavalry lost 25 men.

After the Massacre

The Massacre at Wounded Knee brought an end to the Indian Wars. There was no more resistance. The Ghost Dancing stopped.

The Native Americans had been beaten. But the Cavalry’s attack was recognized as butchery, with Forsyth’s commanding officer, General Nelson Miles, calling it a “criminal military blunder and a horrible massacre of women and children.”

However, President Harrison had an election around the corner and wasn’t in a position to look bad. Miles’ report was dismissed. Instead, the Cavalry men were made out as heroes against the Indian “savages.” And in the Spring of 1891, the president awarded the first of 20 Medals of Honor to the soldiers who disarmed then slaughtered the Sioux at Wounded Knee.

It’s been speculated that the 7th Cavalry, which again was regrouped after it was destroyed by Sitting Bull at Little Bighorn, was looking for a fight and deliberately sought revenge on the Native Americans.

Black Elk, one of the few Lakota survivors of the Wounded Knee Massacre, recalled in 1931: “I can still see the butchered women and children lying heaped and scattered all along the crooked gulch as plain as when I saw with eyes still young. And I can see that something else died there in the bloody mud, and was buried in the blizzard. A people’s dream died there.”

The Wounded Knee Massacre: The Forgotten History of the Native American Gun Confiscation originally appeared in The Resistance Library at Ammo.com.

16 Likes

Added to the things I didn’t learn in school, like the trail of tears

12 Likes

Whaaaaa??? This was a BATTLE in a WAR. Not a slaughter of innocents. This was one army vs another.

Burying the dead in mass graves after a battle is and was normal if the enemy does not recover their dead.

WWI, bomb cites, WW2 bomb cities, Korea bomb cities, Vietnam bomb cities on and on and on.

A professed Democrat who later ran for office.

Normally you don’t give defeated enemy combatants the ability to post in your nations media.

8 Likes

War is hell.
I read my first FIL’s Army Air Force flight records.
He helped burn Dresden and other cities to the ground. Inhabitants included.
I cheered as I read.
THAT’s how you win a war.
War is hell.

8 Likes

And then you have the fact that this “war” was being fought against a population that rightfully “owned” the land they were living on. They were then subsequently rounded up, their property confiscated because they wouldn’t “comply” with the group that told them that their ideology, their religion and their way of life was “wrong” and then were hunted down, interred, or executed by those who deemed that “they knew better”.
Sound familiar?

History is written by the victors.
The vanquished have no voice.

9 Likes

What War - unless you are willing to call it a Civil War.
except for the fact that they were not at war, but living accordingly with the current laws and treaties, that their Government had and was unwilling to abide by.
And they willing disarmed because they BELEIVED that their Government would protect them.

8 Likes

The Battle at Wounded Knee is a significant battle in American history, as it put an end to the Indian Wars and is marked as the last official defeat of the Native Americans

War is an intense armed conflict [a] between states, governments, societies, or paramilitary groups such as mercenaries, insurgents and militias. It is generally characterized by extreme violence, aggression, destruction, and mortality, using regular or irregular military forces. Warfare refers to the common activities and characteristics of types of war, or of wars in general.[2] Total war is warfare that is not restricted to purely legitimate military targets, and can result in massive civilian or other non-combatant suffering and casualties.

6 Likes

guess that means genocide is okay as long as it is gets lumped in with war.
“The Battle of Wounded Knee” would not be a Battle Honor that I would want.
As I recall the Sioux Nation was not at war, but living peacefully on the lands dictated and granted by treaty. And it was the failure of the US Government to abide by and enforce that treaty.
Failure to learn from history - as long as it is done legally and in the name of the government it is morally right by your definition.

8 Likes

No one said that it was right, just not as odd as everyone likes to make it out to be. The native Americans were murdering women and children by the hundreds… Painting them as innocents is political horse crap.

I KNOW my history sir, you are the one referring to soldiers defending their territory from raids by enemy combatants as morally evil.

Great Sioux War of 1876 - Wikipedia - The battles didnt stop until after Crazy horse died.

We are the most merciful nation of ANY that has ever existed on this planet. The fact that you can find a single native American AND that they are nearly completely allowed to exist as they wish OUTSIDE of attempting to take back land they LOST in a FAILED attempt to defend their territory is a SCREAMING example of how merciful as a nation we are.
Go to any other country that was once populated by another people than live there now… You would be hard pressed to find many examples with people being allowed to exist outside of the new local populations requirements.
By no means are we innocent but, as far as treatment of a defeated nation goes we are the example that the world should strive to imitate.

4 Likes

Many stories of untold histories surface and are just as well told as mainstream

We all need to be careful , remember, unless you were actually there you really can’t be certain

6 Likes

I would normally agree, particularly if this was reported as a glowing military victory for the United States and that no wrongdoing was committed. But I have never seen it written this way in a history book.
Its a pretty safe bet that when a nation writes something negative about themselves in their own history that you are getting the story pretty close to the reality.

Factually speaking we are the most humane civilization in the history of the world.

4 Likes

Then explain MyLai,

perfect description of the Sioux - however if you recall your history it is out of context of more than 10 years.

13 years prior to Wounded Knee…

6 Likes

What makes that a fact?

What is humane?

If a convict, say murderer, gets paroled, victimizes more people, is that more humane than
life for life justice?

4 Likes

Awful, still a drop in the bucket compared to ANY other major nation on earth.

The official title of this battle was the battle at wounded knee.
For this 1890 campaign, the US Army awarded 20 Medals of Honor, its highest commendation.[52]

On the morning of December 29, the U.S. Cavalry troops went into the camp to disarm the Lakota. One version of events claims that during the process of disarming the Lakota, a deaf tribesman named Black Coyote was reluctant to give up his rifle, claiming he had paid a lot for it.[7] Simultaneously, an old man was performing a ritual called the Ghost Dance. Black Coyote’s rifle went off at that point; the U.S. Army began shooting at the Native Americans. The Lakota warriors fought back, but many had already been stripped of their guns and disarmed.[8]

This battle COMPLETELY stopped the Indian wars and may have prevented the complete obliteration of an enemy who refused to stop fighting. What nation leaves armed combatants on its territory??
Hiroshima and Nagasaki were evil too?

4 Likes

hu•mane hyoo͞-mān′►

adj.
Characterized by kindness, mercy, or compassion.
adj.
Characterized by an emphasis on humanistic values and concerns.
Of or pertaining to man; human. See human, a.
4 Likes

Do you know why the US Army and Americans in general were disliked by the West German people - they were seen as a occupying force.

A very good friend recounts a story of a pile of disregarded rations piled in the middle of the town square. And the civilian populace attempting to take would be shot the US Army guarding the garbage pile.
What lends credence to that event is from two different personal sources - one who’s sister was shot attempting get food to feed her younger brother and sister.
The fact is nation states are only humane in their own eyes.

6 Likes

image

You are right I cant imagine how wronged the german people were by the American forces, especially after they had not been complacent in any type of activity that might have been an issue for any other member of humanity. :skull: :skull: :skull: :skull:

7 Likes

I stood in the Village of My Lai 9 years after the event, and was it a war crime or fog of war?
My opinion - fog of war.
The Vietnamese government considered it collateral damage but was more than willing to ride that propaganda pony till the legs fell off that the US media was providing them with.

8 Likes

That’s a definition, not an answer

Is it more humane to allow criminals to victimize again?

Is our society really even our own, many Roman traits (many) and even some from the
The Code of Hammurabi like an accused person being considered innocent until proven guilty exist,

I very much doubt facts would reveal we are the most humane

my opinion of course

5 Likes

I will just have to agree to disagree with you two.
I believe that we are the best example of freedom this world has ever known.

6 Likes